The History
of Tetrology of Fallot
(Blue Babies Syndrome)
The congenital heart defect called tetrology
of Fallot is a complex combination of four birth defects
in the heart. Some believe there are only three heart defects.
The spelling of the word tetrology can be spelled either
tetralogy or tetrology. The first part of the word tetralogy
is tetra that is a Greek word that means four.
Tetralogy of Fallot is four defects within
the heart. The four heart defects are;
1. pulmonary stenosis ( a narrowing of pulmonary valve and
the outflow tract creating a blockage or obstruction of
the blood flow from the right ventricle to the pulmonary
artery),
2. a large ventricular septal defect ( a hole in the wall
of the septum of the ventricle)
3. an overriding aorta (the aortic valve is enlarged and
it appears to arise from both the right and left ventricles
instead of only the left ventricle as usually occurring
in the normal hearts) and
4. a right ventricular hypertrophy ( an enlargement of the
right ventricle and the thickening of the muscular walls
of the right ventricle, which occurs because the right ventricle
is pumping blood at a high pressure).
Some children who have ToF also have additional VSD, atrial
septal defects or abnormalities in the branches of the coronary
arteries.
In the heart defect known as pulmonary
stenosis there is a blockage or an obstruction of blood
flow to the lungs resulting from a narrowing of the outflow
area connecting the right ventricle to the pulmonary aorta.
The word Fallot is actually the name of
the doctor who described the four heart defects. The doctor
a French physician and cardiologist name is Ettienne Louis
Arthur Fallot was born in 1850 and died in 1911.

Tetrology of Fallot is also known by the
three letters (ToF) that is an acronym and is also known
as Fallot's Syndrome. Fallot was not the first to describe
the four multiple congenital heart defects.
The first written description of ToF was
by Niels Stensen [Stenonius, Nicolaus] 1638-1686. In a paper
called Embryo monstro affinis Parisiis dissectus. Acta med.
Philos. Hafniensa, 1671-72,1, 202-03.
Niels was a Danish Physician, natural
scientist, bishop and later Saint Nicolaus Stenonius. Fallots
description was from 1888 based on the symptoms of two persons
he observed with the bluish color to the skin and with a
survey of 50 other patients previously noted.
There are at least forty descriptions
of this condition before Fallots description.
Another description is by Sandifort, Eduard
born 1742 died in 1814. Sandifort wrote in a paper, Observationes
anatomicae-pathologicae. Vol.1 Lugduni Batavorum,P.v.d.Eyk&D.
Vygh, 1791. First English translation.

One Thomas Bevill Peacock born 1812 and
died in 1882 wrote in a paper called; On malformations,
etc, of the human heart. London, J. Churchill, 1858. This
includes an account of the "tetralogy of Fallot".
Peacock's book was "the first comprehensive study covering
the whole field" (Maude Abbott)

Fallot, Etienne Louis Arthur, French Physician;
Born September 29, 1850 in Seite that is outside of Marseille,
died April 30, 1911.
He wrote a paper: Contribution a l'anatomie pathologique
de la maladie bleu (cyanose cardique). Marseille med, 1888,
25,77-93. The "tetralogy of Fallot." He gave an
important, but not the first, account of this condition.
What might be of interest to many is to
understand how something takes on the name of a person such
as adding Fallots name to the 4 heart defects called tetrologyof
Fallot.
An EPONYM is a word derived or associated
from some-ones name. If you have ever eaten a sandwich,
this word is named after the Earl of Sandwich. How this
came about was during a sporting event he was being called
away from it. He didn't want to leave so he told his servant
to bring him a serving of meat between two slices of bread
so he wouldn't have to leave. That's how we got the word
sandwich.
A similar story is how we get the name
side-burns that is facial hair. The name came from a man
called Burnside who had long hair on the side of his face.
Associated eponyms:
1. Fallot's Pentalogy- Five defects. This is the four known
defects with the addition of either a patent foramen ovale
or an atrial septal defect. Now we have five defects. Penta
means 5.
2. Fallot's Tetralogy- balanced shunt syndrome. A variation
of Fallot's tetralogy is seen with the characteristics of
occasional spells of cyanosis (skin bluish in color), hyperpnoema
and syncope.
3. Fallot's trilogy- a group of three defects that include
pulmonary stenosis, intraatrial septal defect and a closed
interventricular septum.
4. Fallot's Tetralogy- The four congenital defects that
are stenosis of the pulmonary artery, defects in the inter-ventricular
septum, dextroposition of the aorta, and hypertrophy of
the right ventricle.
Tetrology of Fallot makes up about 10 percent
of all congenital heart defects affecting boys more than
girls. ToF is usually detected some period of time after
birth usually within the first year.
Diagnosis is made by the bluish color
to the skin, nails and lips, problems eating, failure to
gain weight, slow growth and physical development, difficulty
in breathing due to lack of air or painful breathing (dyspnea)
upon exerting oneself, clubbing of fingers and toes and
polycythaemia (many red blood cells).
There may be permanent bluish color to
the skin. This defect is also found in animals such as cattle
and dogs and recently found in a tiger. This bluish color
to body happens because the lungs can't get enough oxygen
in the blood. Remember oxygen is carried by the blood and
if there is not enough blood filled with oxygen we now have
the other kind of blood we call blue blood which has less
oxygen in it or it has given off its oxygen on the way back
to the lungs to refill with oxygen.
The history of Tetralogy of Fallot is another
giant step in the history of heart surgery. Who was the
first to operate on children born with this heart defect,
who thought about the way it could be done, who made it
possible to figure out a way to change the way blood flows
in the heart and vessels is of great wonder.
So many people played a major role in
the evolution of surgery to correct this heart defect that
it is really quite remarkable. We will talk about the closed
heart operation to correct Tof and then the openheart operation
where they actually open the heart to close the defects
in babies born with Tetralogy of Fallot.
The first person we would have to talk about would have
to be the patient who had to bare the problem of having
the heart defects. The color of the skin, lips, fingernails,
how difficult it was for a child to eat, how tired the child
gets and the most common sign that a child has TETRALOGY
of FALLOT is the position the child assumes to be able to
breathe. Squatting down with the head between the legs after
exertion.
Remember that the world famous and first
Lady of pathology of the heart was the Canadian Dr. Maude
Abbott (1869-1940). She and she alone wrote and studied
more about congenital heart defects than anyone in the world.
By her work in studying the hearts of those who died gave
her more of an understanding how the heart worked than anyone
of her time. Indirectly she played a major role in developing
procedures to correct heart defects. All surgeons referred
to her book on congenital heart disease.

The next person who would play a major
role in the correction of TETRALOGY of FALLOT is Dr. Helen
Taussig (1898-1986) from John's Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore
Maryland. Helen was a pediatric cardiologist and for years
had seen children in her practice of pediatric cardiology
medicine with these 4 heart defects known as Tetrology of
Fallot and had no way to help them.
An interesting side note about Helen was
that she was hard of hearing and seldom used a stethescope
to listen to the heart and lungs. She made her diagnosis
by the clinical symptoms a patient came in with and after
a visual inspection and physical hands on examination.
Helen often referred and talked to Maude
Abbott about her work with the pathology of the heart and
it was Dr. Taussig who came up with the idea how to correct
this heart defect. Helen first approached Dr. Robert Gross
from Boston who did the operation on babies and kids who
had a patent ductus arterisosis. From what I have read it
seems he had no interest in this.
The basic idea for the operation was to
be able to get proper oxygenation of the blood from the
lungs. The blue baby operation that Taussig wanted to do
was to join part of the aorta to the pulmonary artery where
the blood would pick up oxygen in the lungs. This is what
Helen spoke of with Maude Abbott.
The next person who Helen spoke with about
trying to help all the kids she had seen with ToF was Dr.
Alfred Blalock (1899-1964) and his surgical assistant in
his lab by the name of Vivien T. Thomas (1910-1985). Blalock
hired Vivien when they both previously worked in Tennessee
at the Vanderbuilt University Hospital. Blalock asked Vivien
to join him at his new position at Hopkins where he would
continue as his surgical assistant. Vivien worked out many
operations on animals in the hospital lab and then took
this into the operating room with Blalock.

There are different stories as to how the
origins of the operation came about and I will share what
Dr. Taussig said. In 1943 Dr. Taussig talked of a conversation
between Dr. Blalock and Dr. Edwards A. Park who hired Dr.
Taussig.
The conversation had to do with the problem
associated with the idea of cross-clamping the descending
aorta to repair the heart defect that Dr. Crafoord from
Sweden and Dr.Gross from America had successfully operated
on called Coarctation of the aorta in 1944 and 1945.
Dr. Park asked Blalock, could you not
use the carotid artery as a bypass? It is a long, straight
artery and there are four blood vessels to the brain. Wouldn't
it be possible to turn the carotid artery down and reconnect
it to the aorta below the coarctation.
Then Dr. Taussig spoke up and said, If
you could put the carotid artery into the descending aorta,
couldn't you put the subclavian artery into the pulmonary
artery (the artery to the lungs to pick up oxygen). This
is called shunting of blood from one area of the heart to
another by disconnecting a blood vessel from where it normally
would be and redirecting the vessel to go somewhere else.

This shunting of blood from the subclavian
artery to the artery to the lung called the pulmonary artery
would pick up oxygen from the lungs and take this oxygenated
blood to the rest of the body.
The first operation for blue babies called
Tetralogy of Fallot was done on November 29, 1944 at Johns
Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore, Maryland. The first patient
was a girl named Eileen Saxon.

Eileen Saxon
This is how Harry Minetree described the
operation with all those who participated.
"On November 29, 1944, students and
professors crowded into the double-deck observation gallery
above the eighth-floor operating room in the Halsted Clinic.
Because there was a danger of losing the child Eileen before
the operation began, Dr. Merel Harmel decided not to use
a strong anaesthetic and put her slowly to sleep with a
diluted mixture of ether and oxygen.

Dr. Blalock operating on TOF patient at Hopkins.
Dr. William Longmire, the Chief Resident,
was first assistant. Charlotte Mitchell was the scrub nurse.
After inserting an arterial needle for blood-oxygen tests,
Vivien Thomas, who in the dog lab had proved himself a master
at vascular suturing, stood by in the event that his advice
might be needed.

Dr. Longmire
Dr. Denton Cooley administered fluids.
The tiny, pliable ribs were retracted and the pleural cavity,
containing the child's atrophied lungs and small, twisted
heart, was opened
the heart and lungs seemed infinitely
more complex in miniature.

With the assistance of Thomas, Dr. Blalock
found the subclavian artery, clamped it at its origin and
began dissecting away the tissue that clung to it. The instruments
were too large and awkward
Using bulldog clamps fitted
with rubber tubing so as not to crush the vessels, Blalock,
with Thomas' help, carefully prepared a site for attaching
the subclavian to the pulmonary artery. A small transverse
incision was made between two clamps on the pulmonary artery
then, using china beaded silk on fine needles, Dr. Blalock
completed the juncture that rerouted the baby's blood. She
immediately went from waxen blue to pink. Dr. Helen Taussig
had watched the operation from the head of the table
."

This was the beginning of what is called
palliative correction of correcting the heart defect Tetrology
of Fallot. It was not a cure but a way to give patients
a better life until another better way to correct these
4 heart defects could be accomplished. The use of the subclavian
artery and the pulmonary artery was the first operation.
In their first article that was published
Dr. Blalock and Taussig said that the SHUNT operation might
be able to be used to treat conditions such as tetrology
of fallot, pulmonary atresia, truncus arteriosus, and single
ventricle with a rudimentary outflow chamber and a diminutive
pulmonary artery. They also stated emphasizing that it was
applicable only with anomalies associated with reduced pulmonary
(lung) blood flow.
The first three children to be operated
on at Johns Hopkins for Tetrology of Fallot each had a different
anatomical shunt operation and each showed striking postoperative
improvement. The first child had a normal arch, a left subclavian
end-to-side pulmonary artery anastamosis.
The second child had a right arch and
underwent an innominate end-to-side left pulmonary artery
shunt. The third child had an arch that was on the left
and had an innominate end-to-side right pulmonary artery
anastamosis. The doctors talked about every possible and
conceiveable way of constructing a systemic-pulmonary union
with the exception of using a graft. The methods included
the side-to-side aortic pulmonary anastamosis used by Dr.
Willis John Potts (1895-1968) later on.
Let it be understood that the operation
that Dr. Blalock, Dr. Taussig, and Dr. Vivien Thomas gave
a new outlook on life to patients. It gave a joyous outlook
and relief to the parents of these children who found themselves
totally helpless caring for their children. This surgical
procedure of rerouting blood by disconnecting one blood
vessel and joining it to another was a blessing to all involved.
Dr. Blalock, Vivien Thomas and Dr. Taussig
made medical history with this medical breakthrough. Surgeons
from around the world came to learn how to do the operation
called the Blalock-Taussig Shunt. The next two patients
Blalock, Thomas and Taussig did was different from the first
Both Taussig and Blalock traveled the
world teaching their operation. On one occasion while speaking
at a conference in England they were showing slides of a
patient who they had done the Blalock-Taussig Shunt operation
on and a nurse walked the little patient in to show the
doctors. The room was silent and then a roaring ovation
came from the doctors in the auditorium.
Little Eileen Saxon the first patient
to have the Blalock- Taussig Shunt Operation for Tetrology
of Fallot survived only a year. Many children came from
all over America and the world to have the operation done
at Johns Hopkins Hospital. Many doctors learned the operation
at Hopkins and took this knowledge to the hospital they
were working at and started to do operations on their patients
who had Tetrology of Fallot.
Another major surgical breakthrough came
about with the actual opening of the heart to repair the
4 heart defects seen in Tetrology of Fallot. Remember the
operation that Blalock, Thomas, and Taussig developed did
not involve opening the heart to correct the defects. They
did open the skin and bones in the chest, but not the heart.
Their method was to make life bearable by bringing more
oxygen to the body by rerouting blood vessels. Keep in mind
that they had very little equipment back then and they had
nowhere near the diagnostic equipment that we have today
to make a diagnosis or help in the operation.
The next major step in treating Blue Babies
or people with Tetrology of Fallot took place almost 10
years later. We will go back to the University of Minnesota
Hospital and the surgeon who had developed an open-heart
surgical procedure for a heart condition known as Ventricular
Septal Defect.
Remember baby Gregory Glidden was operated
on for a VSD and survived 11 days and didn't survive due
to pneumonia. There were 2 other children in the hospital
at the same time as baby Gregory.
A boy named Bradly and a girl named Pamela
who both had ventricular septal defects. Both were operated
on and Bradly became the first long term survivor of the
heart defect called Ventricular septal defect and Pamela
was the first girl.
Both are alive and doing fairly well as
of this writing as I have spoken to them both and will share
much more in the section on the heart defect called Ventricular
Septal Defects.
There was also another boy in the University
Hospital at the same time as Bradly and Pamela. This boy
Mark had a different heart defect called Tetrology of Fallot.
Up to this point in time no one had literally cut open the
heart to try and correct the four birth defects within the
heart that were seen in blue babies. That was to change
and another first was to be accomplished.
On August 31, 1954 a child named Mark Shaw
was brought to the operating room at the University of Minnessota
Hospital. Ten years earlier on November 29, 1944 Blalock,
Thomas and Taussig operated on Eileen Saxon to correct her
4 heart defects called Tetrology of Fallot. During this
operation they did not cut open the heart. They rerouted
blood vessels to bring more oxygen to the body.

This was going to change on August 31,
1954. The operation was going to be a first in two ways.
The boy was going to have his heart opened up and the surgeons
Drs. Walt Lillehi, Varco, Warden and Cohen were going to
do a first by using the blood from another person called
cross circulation to oxygenate the patient's blood.
The donor was not a member of the patient's
family. The boy had a rare blood type AB- and no one in
his family had this blood type. The Red Cross was contacted
and a man age 29 and father of 3 volunteered to be the cross
circulation donor. Marks parents were told about the operation
that was done at Hopkins for Tetrology of Fallot invented
by Blalock and Taussig, but Lillehi didn't think the boy
could survive two surgeries the Blalock Taussig Shunt and
then the openheart operation he planned to do.
The University of Minnesota surgeons hooked
up their young patient Mike to the blood stream of his cross
circulation donor Howard Holtz both under anesthesia next
to each other in the operating room.
This was a first for the donor was not
related to the patient. This was also a first multi-type
operation of the heart series in which more than one defect
was corrected. The donor Mr. Holtz body would serve as a
living heart-lung machine for the young patient Mike. A
small pump would help move the blood through the plastic
tubing connecting Mr. Holtz femoral artery and saphenous
vein in his legs to the artery and vein in Michael's neck
and most importantly Mr. Holtz lungs would put oxygen into
the blood being pumped through both Mike and Mr. Holtz.
This would give the surgeons about 13 minutes to fix the
defects within the heart.
Mikes heart was opened and it was bloodless.
Inside the doctors closed up a hole between the right and
left ventricle (known as an inter-ventricular defect) and
removed tissue obstruction at the opening leading from the
heart to the main artery that carries the blood to the lungs
called the pulmonary artery.
Dr. Lillehi explained that this obstruction
was keeping the blood from reaching the lungs in the proper
quantities and was building up a pressure inside the heart.
Total surgery time was 3 hours.
When Mr. And Mrs. Shaw say Michael they
couldn't believe that his fingernails, lips and ears were
no longer blue. They were reddish pink. Mrs. Shaw said before
the operation Mike could not walk a half a block without
having to rest.
This operation for Tetrology of Fallot
was the first of its kind opening the heart for multiple
heart defects and using a donor's blood as a heart lung
machine for cross-circulation made medical history.
Both procedures the Blalock-Taussig Shunt
and the openheart operation for Tetrololgy of Fallot by
Lillehi and associates are still done today. Many of the
surgical procedures have been improved but are still the
basis for helping those affected by this group of defects.
|